Flavour pairings

Chocolate spreads: beyond the jar

A chocolate spread can put nuts, cocoa, milk or caramel in the leading role. Looking at those choices makes the jar more interesting than a simple sweet topping.

Published

Dark cocoa and pale nut spreads in unlabelled jars, with spoonfuls and two slices of the same plain bread.
Compare a spread on its own, then on the same plain bread to notice flavour and texture.

What leads the flavour?

A spread's name does not tell you which ingredient you will notice first. Callebaut's work on spreads treats bases such as chocolate, nuts, caramel and fruit as different routes to flavour and texture. One jar may be strongly cocoa-led; another may use chocolate chiefly to support a nut. Read the ingredient list, then taste a little on its own before adding bread or a dessert.

Linden's Macadamia White Chocolate Spread took a nut-forward route. The product description put macadamias at approximately 40% of the mixture, with milk and a little cane sugar. Its white-chocolate character therefore differs from a dark cocoa and hazelnut spread. Calling both 'chocolate spread' is useful for the shelf, but too broad for describing their flavour.

Read the jar before choosing a pairing

The first few ingredients tell you more about a spread's direction than the picture on the front. On UK prepacked foods, ingredients are listed in descending order by weight; a named ingredient may also have a percentage. Compare where nuts, sugar, cocoa and added fats appear on two jars, then check the nutrition panel if sweetness matters to your choice. A nut-led spread and a sugar-led cocoa spread can both be enjoyable, but they will not taste or spread alike. The label helps you choose the question to test, not declare one jar the winner.

Keep the jar's storage directions in view, especially when comparing a shelf-stable product with a freshly made spread. Check the label for milk and tree nuts if sharing, and use clean separate spoons for different jars.

Texture is part of the experience

A spread also has a texture: loose or dense, glossy or grainy, quick to melt or slow to coat the palate. Callebaut notes that nut paste can round a chocolate spread and make it easier to spread. The type and amount of nut, together with the chocolate and other ingredients, will affect the result. Compare texture separately from sweetness so a very sweet jar does not automatically become your idea of a creamy one.

Try the spread from a clean spoon, then on a neutral piece of bread. The bread changes both texture and perceived sweetness, so the two tastes may give different answers. If comparing jars, use the same base for each. Otherwise a strongly flavoured cracker or pastry can become the main event.

Give macadamia room to show

Linden suggested its macadamia spread on bread, particularly rye. Rye gives a more assertive backdrop than a very soft white loaf. With a macadamia or white-chocolate spread of your choice, try both kinds of bread and see which brings the nutty and creamy notes forward. Toasted and untoasted rye offer another comparison because warmth and crunch change the bite.

A thin layer is enough for the first taste. Then try more if you want a richer impression. When discussing the spread with someone else, ask whether they notice macadamia, milk or sweetness first. The order may change once it is on bread. That is more informative than deciding only whether it is 'nice'.

Compare spreads fairly

If you have several spreads, separate them by their leading ingredient: nut, dark cocoa, white chocolate or caramel. Taste from mild to strong, and keep the portions modest. A dark cocoa spread may leave a persistent finish that makes a delicate white-chocolate version harder to read afterwards. A little water and plain bread between samples helps keep the comparison useful.

Linden's The Chocolate Tastings gift box combined small bars with two selected spreads. That format suggests a good at-home exercise: compare a solid piece of chocolate with a spread, focusing on how the flavour arrives and fades in each texture. Do not assume a spread is simply a melted version of a bar; its ingredients and proportions can be quite different.

Simple ways to serve a spread

For a use beyond toast, put a small amount on plain yoghurt or a warm crêpe and add only one other flavour, perhaps fresh fruit. A tart berry may change a cocoa-heavy spread differently from a creamy nut spread; a banana may make either feel softer and sweeter. Try the spread on its own first, then with the base, before adding toppings. The Belgian Chocolate Makers' pairing guide makes this distinction between the spread's own flavour and what the serving food contributes.

Follow the label on any jar you have for storage and use. To enjoy it, identify the leading ingredient, notice the texture and choose a serving base that suits both.

Further reading